Devils Outside, Devils Inside, Devils of the View: Patrül Rinpoche’s Text on Diagnosing and Avoiding Maras, Part II

Painting of maras attacking the Buddha, by Balinese artist Pande Ketut Bawa

Here is part II of a multi-part series in which I share a preliminary translation of a text on Maras – ‘demonic’ obstacles on the spiritual path – by the nineteenth century Tibetan Buddhist teacher Patrül Rinpoche. As I mentioned in Part I, this text is Patrül’s reworking of an earlier text by the twelfth century Kadampa master Chegompa (see Part I for more details). In the opening section of the text, Chegompa describes the Four General Maras – these maras are ‘general’ because they are overarching, they encompass the obstacles and challenges of samsaric broadly. In this next Part, Chegom outlines three levels of specific or particular maras – chedrak ki dü, བྱེ་བྲག་གི་བདུད་ – namely, outer level maras, inner level maras, and secret level maras. There are six types for each level, making eighteen specific maras in total. The scheme of ‘outer, inner, secret’ – chi nang sang sum, ཕྱི་ནང་གསང་གསུམ་ in Tibetan – will be familiar to many readers. It is an ubiquitous framework in Tibetan Buddhism and charts a spectrum from other beings and gross, external, objective reality on one end, to more internal, intangible, personal, and subjective experiences and orientations on the other. Let’s dive right into the translation (I’ll include some reflections on the section at the end!).

Continue reading →

Four Common Devils: Patrül Rinpoche’s Text on Diagnosing and Avoiding Maras, Part I

A nineteenth century tangka painting of the Buddha conquering maras, housed at Rubin Museum of Himalayan Art, purchased from the Collection of Navin Kumar, New York. See here for more details.

In the interest of starting to post here a bit more regularly, I figured I would share, in installments, a rough translation of an interesting Tibetan text I came across recently. The text is by Dza Patrül Rinpoche (1808 – 1887 – Patrül has become the quasi-standard English phoneticization, but it could just as well be Peltrül), a prominent scholar-practitioner of the Nyingma school of Tibetan Buddhism, who is perhaps best known today for his extensive commentary on the ngöndro, i.e. the foundational, preliminary practices of the Longchen Nyingthig system, called ཀུན་བཟང་བླ་མའི་ཞལ་ལུང་ Künzang Lamé Zhelung, ‘The Direct Oral Instructions of the Guru who is one and the same as Samantabhadra’, better-known as ‘Words of My Perfect Teacher’. The text I’d like to share here is, also included in Patrül Rinpoche’s collected works and is titled བདུད་ཀྱི་རྒྱུ་བརྟགས་ཏེ་སྤོང་ཚུལ་གྱི་མན་ངག་བདུད་ལས་རྣམ་རྒྱལ་ ‘Complete Victory over Mara: Pith Instructions on how to Diagnose the Causes of Mara or Obstructing Demons and the Methods for Avoiding Them’. I cited the final paragraph from this ‘Complete Victory over Mara’ text in a recent interview I did with Steve James on the Guru Viking podcast on the Tibetan concept of gek or obstacles which arise in the course of meditation and spiritual practice. As it happens, the text is not an original composition, but as Patrül explains in the colophon, is his reworking of a chapter by the same name found in ‘The Heap of Precious Pith Oral Instructions’ མན་ངག་རིན་ཆེན་སྤུངས་པ་ Mengngak Rinchen Pungpa, a treatise by the influential Tibetan Kadampa master Chegompa, who was born in 1130. Patrül Rinpoche notes that he has summarized the original chapter, has edited its wording slightly, in order to rework it into ‘notes’ or a more bulleted form (ཟིན་ཐུན་དུ་སྤེལ་བ་). This is very kind of him, since it makes the key points of Chegompa’s chapter easier for students like us to access, study, and memorize. Since there’s so much of interest in the text, I’d like to share it in its entirety here, with a few personal reflections along the way.

Continue reading →

New Interview on ‘Meditation Sickness’ and Tibetan Geksel Literature on Guru Viking

A quick post here to call attention to yet another interview I did with Steve James for his Guru Viking podcast, which came out a day ago.

In the interview, Steve and I discuss two pieces of research I recently did on the subject of so-called ‘meditation sickness’ and the Tibetan genre of geksel, gegs sel གེགས་སེལ་, i.e. instructions and practices for resolving obstacles – adverse reactions, sicknesses and so on – which get in the way of accomplishing meditation and yogic practice. Both pieces of research were developed with the kind editorial support and encouragement of Dr Pierce Salguero – the first, an annotated interview with Dr Nida Chenagtsang, a Tibetan traditional doctor and tantric householder yogi, which is featured in Pierce’s recent University of Hawaii Press edited volume ‘Meditation Sickness: A Sourcebook on the Dangers of Buddhist Practice’ and the other, an annotated translation of a Tibetan gegs sel manual written by the seventeenth century Tibetan meditation master Taranatha, which will be appearing in an upcoming special volume of the Asian Medicine Journal.

Geksel literature is such a fascinating genre of Tibetan writing and knowledge. It sits at the rich intersection of medicine and Tantric Buddhist yoga, of exoteric and naturalistic and esoteric and ritual approaches to healing. It’s also been surprisingly under-researched and discussed. I’ve learned a great deal comparing and contrasting Tibetan geksel texts – I hope that the conversation and these modest research contributions will inspire further interdisciplinary conversations and research as well. Here’s Steve’s description and timestamps for the interview:

Continue reading →

On Interactions with Spirits in Tibetan Buddhism: New Interview on the Guru Viking Podcast

A 19th century Tibetan tangka or religious painting depicting Nyenchen Tanglha, an important Tibetan territorial protector deity associated with the sacred mountain range of the same name

A quick note to say I have a new interview up on the Guru Viking Podcast, hosted by Steve James. This one is supposed to be the first of three chats focusing on human-spirit interactions and relationships in different esoteric or magical traditions. Here’s some links, and a list of topics we touched on, as prepared by Steve for the time stamps. Let me know what you think!

Continue reading →

Dr Nida Chenagtsang’s Research into Reviving Yookchö or Tibetan Stick Therapy

After more than a year’s hiatus (hello, PhD dissertation), I thought I would revive my posting here with a translation of an essay by Tibetan physican and tantric yogi Dr Nida Chenagtsang about a different kind of revival.

The following essay, published in a 1999 edited collection of some of Dr Nida’s articles on Tibetan medicine, describes Dr Nida’s efforts to resuscitate and promote a traditional Tibetan healing practice known as Yookchö/Yukcho(e) (dbyug bcos), or ‘Stick Therapy’. Stick Therapy, also sometimes called ‘vajra-stick/rod’ (rdo rje dbyug) practice, involves tapping repeatedly and in a steady rhythm on particular treatment points on a patient’s or one’s own body with a specially prepared pliable stick with a  bundle or knob on one end in order to treat specific ailments. Stick Therapy is one of several traditional Tibetan healing practices which were originally (or simultaneously) developed by tantric Buddhist yogi/nis for use on their own bodies for the purposes of self-healing in the context of meditation retreat, which were then apparently taken up and developed as more exoteric medical therapies for use on the bodies of uninitiated patients.

Continue reading →

‘Master of Ceremonies’: A Review of Julio Cesar Ody’s New Book on Solomonic Magic

spirit pot julio

I recently had a quick read through of Julio Cesar Ody’s new book on the subject of Solomonic spirit evocation, ‘Magister Officiorum: The Ceremony of Solomonic Magic’ just published by Scarlet Imprint, and I thought I would share some initial, cursory thoughts here.

This is a deceptively slim volume, admirably concise yet nonetheless richly evocative (see what I did there). Its pages breathe lived experience (Julio is a seasoned Solomonic magician and initiate of Brazilian, Haitian, and Jamaican magical traditions) and Julio engages with his readers in an honest, matter-of-fact, unblinking fashion. Continue reading →

Anthropology, Esotericism, and ‘Fringe’ Buddhism: Interview on the Imperfect Buddha Podcast

devil-woodcut

A month or two ago I did an interview with Matthew O’Connell for his ‘Imperfect Buddha’ podcast, where I talked about doing research on Western esotericism as an anthropologist and scholar-practitioner, and about some of the more ‘fringe’ dimensions of global Tibetan Buddhism today. I ended up talking a lot about myself and not that much about the specific details of my research, and Matthew barely got a word in edgeways, but it is what it is. Many of the posts and articles on this blog get a mention. I no doubt said a lot of things that would benefit from further qualification and which I would probably take issue with if I heard myself saying them now. The thought of listening to my voice drone on for that long curdles my juices and fills me with acute horror though, so I’m can’t be sure – you’ll just have to listen to the interview yourselves and tell me how it makes you feel instead.

Shout out to Matt for arranging things, and thinking I was interesting enough to have on the show. Let me know what you think!

https://posttraditionalbuddhism.com/2016/07/27/8-0-imperfect-buddha-podcast-ben-joffe-on-the-paranormal-tibetan-buddhism-the-ngakpa/

 

‘As Wealthy as a King’: Common Tools and Substances used in Mantra Healing

10403621_860892917278683_1693782508765882216_n

(A regal-looking Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche (1910-1991), with tantric ritual bell or dril bu, seated behind a sbyin sreg or ‘burnt offering’ fire)

As a follow-up to my recent translation of Dr Nida Chenagtang’s chapter on how mantras work, I decided to translate a subsequent chapter in Dr Nida’s Mantra Healing book which deals with the ritual tools and substances most commonly used by ngakpa/ma. Dr Nida la gives a brief summary of some of the most salient ritual implements and objects used by mantra-healers and tantric wizards, and describes their functions, rationale, and construction, along with rules for their proper handling and use. The subject of ritual tools necessarily ties in which more general, theoretical reflections I have made on this blog about the role of materiality in magic and religion. How ought we to understand the status of magical, blessed or powerful objects or materials, in a Buddhist context where nothing that exists has any innate or enduring substantiality on the ultimate level, or for that matter where subtle, ‘imagined forms’ may be just as ontologically real, agentive, and efficacious as gross, material ones? As we saw in Dr Nida’s earlier chapter about mantras’ efficacy, the ultimate emptiness of phenomena is in fact directly related to their functionality or agency – it is precisely because material things are impermanent, compounded and conditional, that they are able to be transformed, and to transform in kind. Buddhist notions of dependent-origination and emptiness are wholesale dispensations that apply across divides of body-and-mind, real-and-representational, which are themselves also categories that operate quite differently in Buddhist philosophical contexts versus non-Buddhist ones. Continue reading →

Demon Directories: On Listing and Living with Tibetan Worldly Spirits

blue thebrang.jpg

(An image of a blue the’u rang or tebrang spirit from a Tibetan manuscript. Scanned images from this manuscript of many Tibetan worldly spirits described in the post that follows can be found here at himalayanart.org but unfortunately the name and date of the source-text is not given. If anyone knows these details, please do let me know!)

I came across the following condensed directory of worldly spirits, gods, demons and other non-human Tibetan persons that go bump in the night in a book of essays which deal with the history and controversies surrounding the Tibetan protector-spirit Dolgyal, which I briefly discussed here. The book, whose short title is ‘The Impurity-Dispelling Mirror – An Investigation into the Origination and Controversy of Dolgyal’ was compiled by the Office of the Central Executive Committee of Dhomay (Amdo) Province in exile. The Committee spent some four odd years conducting research into the contentious spirit’s origins and nature and has penned a series of excellent essays explaining the role of spirit-protectors in Tibetan Buddhism and the development of the controversial sectarian issues associated with this spirit in particular. The essays in the book provide much needed context for a very complex issue, part of which revolves around divided opinions on the theological status of the spirit in question. Supporters of the spirit claim that it is a legitimate protector that is upholding its vows and deserving of propitiation; whereas His Holiness the Dalai Lama and numerous other authorities consider the being to be a harmful and demonic presence, a difficult to control hyper-zealous (and hyper-sectarian) force of violence and evil that should be avoided altogether. Continue reading →

‘His Weight in Gold’: Women of Power in Game of Thrones and Tibetan Buddhism (*SPOILERS!)

melisandre

FOR THE INTERNET IS DARK AND FULL OF SPOILERS! GAME OF THRONES AND TIBETAN BUDDDHIST SPOILERS AHEAD FOR THOSE WHO HAVE NOT WATCHED THE MOST RECENT EPISODE OF THE SERIES OR HAVE NOT ACHIEVED ENLIGHTENMENT!

Last week’s episode of Game of Thrones, the second in this current season, saw fans’ questions about whether we’d be seeing more of a moving version of the Lord Commander of the Night’s Watch Jon Snow put to rest. Continue reading →